Is there a test area? xyz123abc

Good evening.

This new interface offers different, sometimes less or sometimes more formatting options.

It is helpful for users to have a test area to learn the new formatting options. The other larger forums I use here in Germany all have this, without prior discussion! The preview window is not really suitable for this, nor is the possibility to save a draft… The latter is too shaky, I have already lost data several times.

Thank you,

Sven

Translated with www.DeepL.com/Translator (free version)

DE-Version:

Guten Abend.

Diese neue Oberfläche bietet andere, manchmal weniger oder manchmal mehr Möglicheiten der Formatierung.

Für Nutzer ist es durchaus hilfreich, einen Test-Bereich zu haben, um jeweils für sich die sich neu eröffnenden Formatierungsmöglichkeiten zu lernen. Die anderen größeren Foren, in denen ich hier in Deutschland unterwegs bin, haben das alle, ohne vorherige Disskussion! Das Vorschau-Fenster ist dafür nicht wirklich geeignet, auch nicht die Möglichkeit, einen Entwurf zu speichern… Letzteres ist zu wackelig, da hab ich schon mehrfach Datenverlust erlitten.

Danke,

Sven

PS:
Please switch off the automatisms!

Original title is:

DE: Gibt es einen Testbereich?
EN: Is there a test area?

With the original title I get the message:

Title seems unclear, most words contain the same letters over and over.
OK

Error DE:
Titel scheint unklar zu sein, die meisten Wörter enthalten immer wieder die gleichen Buchstaben.
OK

That’s why the xyz123abc in the title…

This is annoying…

1 Like

Part 1 (Test area) has been discussed here. Just for information, maybe there will be further input from the international community.

Part 2 (automated messages) are some kind of pain in the … Another complain about this nonsense here. For every new topic you get the same nonsense messages from Discourse. This feature would be helpful if Discourse would be able to find topics which are really related to the actual one but that does not seem to be the case. Maybe this issue should be shifted to a separate topic by one of the @moderators ?

As mentioned in the German thread, it is possible to send a personal message with yourself as the only recipient. You can reply to this message, quote it, and so on – just like you can in a public thread. This allows you to freely experiment with formatting and other features of the Discourse user interface.

8 Likes

It’s not pretty… It is stored in the database anyway and with such test entries it should not matter that it is public or not… In my opinion, it makes it easier for the user to offer him such an area… It’s up to him whether he uses it or not… Everything else may be possible, but it is not practicable.

Setting up such a test area should only be 2-3 mouse clicks, combined with the will to want to do so in the first place.

Original DE version:

Schön ist das nicht… Das wird doch eh in der Datenbank gespeichert und bei solchen Testeinträgen sollte es egal sein, daß es öffentlich ist oder nicht… Meiner Meinung nach macht man es dem Nutzer einfacher, ihm einen solchen Bereich anzubieten… Ober er es nutzt, ist dann seine Sache… Alles andere mag zwar möglich sein, ist aber nicht praktikabel.

Einen solchen Testbreich einzurichten sollte nur 2-3 Mausklicks sein, verbunden mit dem Willen, das überhaupt zu wollen.

Sven

A testing category might be helpful for (new) moderators who want to test out various platform capabilities without screwing up normal posts. Once such a category has been set up, normal users should of course also be able to do some testing there.

NB. categories can be restricted to dedicated groups, i.e. a moderator only category for tesitng purposes would also be feasible.

I have to disagree. I myself tested lots and lots of markdown codes for the formatting of the “Tipps und Tricks” site by simply using the preview pane of the editor and apparently many other users did so as well. There are some 3.000 users registered and many of them very active but no one has requested for a test area so far. Not that I would oppose one but considering the facts my impression is that a test area is not the most important feature to be added to the forum.

2 Likes

If we are talking about a subcategory of the forum where users can create, modify and delete posts without disturbing the rest of the community and not bothering about certain rules applying in the general forum, then markdown formatting is just one of many use cases. Such a subcategory could as well be used to play around with and try out Discourse features or investigate suspected malfunctions.

2 Likes

Wie wäre folgender Vorschlag, da dir Vorschau und PNs an die eigene Adresse zu kompliziert sind:
Nutze diesen Faden zum editieren, studieren, zitieren, probieren, parlieren, kapieren? :heart_eyes:

Falls sich ein Juser dran stören sollte, wird er dich schon flaggen :japanese_goblin: oder es möge fie gesammelte Meute der Motz über dich herfallen. :japanese_goblin: :japanese_goblin:

:fondue::zap:

I would suggest to start with lowest hanging fruit proposal: Sending a PM to yourself (or @discobot) to experiment first and see if that’s enough or if there is something else needed.

2 Likes