Mapbox, Missing roads

Hello OSM community of Canada.
Mapbox team has been mapping missing roads since May in USA, as described here: Mapbox Organized Editing, Missing Roads

This project has been a success, and we are preparing to expand the effort beyond the US. We’re sharing notice here to ensure that you as a community outside of America have adequate notice, consistent with the Organised Editing Guidelines.

  1. Link to the Github ticket.
  2. List of data team members.
  3. Link to our Wiki page.

And this post is the location we will monitor for suggestions, questions, and concerns. Thanks!

Evgeniya Karnaukhava (jmty8)
osm-edit-escalations@mapbox.com

Given the number of contributors/km2 in Canada, I can only welcome such an initiative!

My only concern at the moment is about the edits made to the geometry of existing roads.

I take particular care (almost compulsive?) to improve the accuracy of the road I update. For instance, I use Strava Global Heatmap (GPS) whenever possible, simply because it provides a much more reliable and accurate reference than OSM tracks to shift the images.

Can you provide more details on the sources used to edit/improve the geometry of existing roads?

Hello @jfd553, right now we’re using all available sources on OSM.
Also usually we’re fixing existing roads if it’s a really bad geometry (ex. TIGER roads from 2007).

1 Like