Is it possible to split the various Communities down further into sub-Communities?
e.g. for the Oceania community, could we then split it further by having Oceania-Australia; Oceania-New Zealand etc?
The way this site is currently configured, thatâs not possible. There is a max_category_nesting setting available which could be set by people with server access and which would allow this, but under the default configuration, one level of nesting is the maximum.
The reason why Discourse works this way by default is that the Discourse developers want to encourage people to use tags instead of categories for this. Not sure if this fits your use case. I am aware that discoverability is a major downside of tags.
5 Likes
If you want to encourage the use of tags it would help if more users would be able to add or modify them.
Right now, you need to be on level 3 which I suspect to be a small group (sorry, have no numbers) and which is even downgraded to level 2 once you are inactive for a few weeks.
3 Likes
You can create âvirtual categoriesâ by combining categories and tags like https://community.openstreetmap.org/search?q=%23communities%3Aoceania%20tags%3Aaustralia%20order%3Alatest.
âaustraliaâ and ânew zealandâ exist as tags, for the other countries I suspect that the local moderators and level 3 users could just keep an eye on new topics and create geographical tags as needed. Thatâs broadly what Iâve been doing for new topics in Help and Support - if it really applies to e.g. Wales, add that as a tag.
1 Like
In my estimation, one of the factors hampering the U.S. communityâs adoption of United States is the coarseness of nationwide subcategories. There are some things we like to discuss as a national community, but there are also other things that need a more intimate local community to feel like we can first achieve a local consensus on something. This subcategory technically hasnât yet reached Dunbarâs number in terms of who participates, but it certainly does in terms of the addressable audience. People really hesitate to post to a national audience.
Back when the U.S. mappers primarily communicated on the talk-us mailing list, discussions about how to format highway refs or classify places often happened in private messages or e-mail exchanges among cliques of mappers. These discussions became much more productive and manageable once the community adopted Slack, where users can create new channels with abandon. Some #local- channels are quite popular (while others are veritable ghost towns).
Tags are helpful, but they feel like more of a way to manage information overload than to foster a sense of community. As far as I know, the only other Discourse feature that seems to speak to this need would be Discourse Chat. An arbitrary number of chat channels can be tied to a single forum subcategory, so in principle we could create a chat channel for each of the states, maybe some of the big cities too. I think this would help a bit, since local conversations tend to be more casual than national ones.
2 Likes
Thanks for that, as the US Slack threads were exactly the example I was thinking of.
As mentioned previously, weâre trying to get OSM Oceania up & running, so having a way that people in Fiji, Micronesia, Tuvalu etc can talk to each other about their issues, rather than being drowned out by Australian discussions, would be great!
2 Likes
Thatâs what the Oceania category was originally designed for: About the Oceania category
Given that we are currently down to two moderators for Oceania I think youâll be struggling to find enough people to moderate if we start breaking up the category (eg: one of the moderators is from NZ, so we canât really even split off AU)
You can combine categories and tags so for example this list is within the the âOceaniaâ category, but tagged ânew_zealandâ. Iâd imagine that something similar would work for places other than âaustraliaâ and ânew_zealandâ (which seem not to have tags currently).
Yeap, that would be me 
Only the post 2022 posts have tags as the rest were imported, and tagging old posts brings them up to the top of the list Unwanted necroposting - #4 by Xvtn
1 Like
Creating tags âas you goâ should avoid that - so that if someone posts about Tuvalu, someone with enough rights to create tags can tag it as such while it is still new.