I just added gtfs analysis to ptna for
- IL-MOT
- Israel
- from Ministry of Transport
- GTFS is available at IL-MOT
- based on discussion Import: Bus stops from GTFS, started at contribution #9
From my point of view, the GTFS does not follow the GTFS recommendations:
- each route (route_id) represents exactly one shape/path/route with several trips (trip_id) providing service at different hours:minutes but follow the same path
- each of the routes can be seen as a route variant in OSM terms
- have a look at tram ‘2’ in IL-MOT
- where both have only one trip (representative trip in PTNA) each
- first route_id
- second route_id
- the second trip_id corresponds to the first trip_id as it is just the return route
- where both have only one trip (representative trip in PTNA) each
PTNA will complain when each route variant in OSM has it’s own gtfs:route_id and the route_master does not have a gtfs:route_id. This can be solved by adding a new analysis option, skipping this kind of test. But: GTFS is wrong/strange here. I’ve seen that also for PL-24-ZTM-Katowice.