Marking that entrance=staircase/main has no sign with code (in area where it is to be expected)

Help and support Tagging help & support
,
1

In some countries buildings with multiple entrances, there will be entrance code assigned to each.

So there will be entrance=staircase ref=19 and so on, and it would be typical to give visitors instructions in form “Zielona Street 9, entrance 19, flat 278”

Is there some accepted/reasonable tagging for “I checked this entrance in area where entrances are expected to have signs, and there was nothing signed there?” What about ref:signed=no ?

(triggered by https://github.com/streetcomplete/StreetComplete/issues/3064 )

2

the typical way would be noref=yes, as we do with noname=yes
also already used in significant numbers:
https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/keys/noref

you even edited the wikipage yourself: Difference between revisions of "Key:noref" - OpenStreetMap Wiki
maybe I misunderstood you, do you want to tag there is a ref but not sign for it?

3

I want to tag that there is no sign and ref maybe is present or maybe not.

Though maybe noref=yes outright is also viable.

4

I think if there could be a ref but the only thing for sure is it is not signed, then your original proposal is fine: ref:signed=no

1 Like
5

Might be nitpicking, but I’d say put noref=yes at first, and if you (or anyone) find that ref does exists somewhere, add it and ref:signed=no. Start simple, assume that if not signed it probably doesn’t exists anywhere and expand when you know more.

My 2 cents.

1 Like
6

Might be nitpicking, but I’d say put ref=no at first, and if you (or anyone) find that ref does exists somewhere, add it and ref:signed=no. Start simple, assume that if not signed it probably doesn’t exists anywhere and expand when you know more.

ref=no is not suitable because it can be easily confused with ref=no
:wink:

7

Sorry, I edited my post. :blush: I took me a while to understand your point (which makes it only more valid) ! :wink:

1 Like
8

For me noref=yes means “no assigned reference”, not “unsigned reference, status unclear”

While ref:signed=no means “unsigned reference, reference code may or may not be assigned” rather than “reference code is assigned but not signed”

2 Likes