I have missused a tag.. Some time ago, maybe?

General talk
1

I suspect I have tagged tactile pavement and some other surface tags wrong and would like to recheck them. This is a problem I have always had but Street Complete highlighted it again, I realized that I interpreted the same tag differently when reading the translation from english into other languages.

Is there some tool around where I can look at how I tagged something historically, e.g. of things I would like to know is when I used tags, with what extra tags, where, which has been replaced or removed, and on what type of geometry.

Going through all the changes with Street Complete takes a while, and it would be nice to see how I have evolved in 20 years of mapping.

1 Like
2

I’d be interested in the answer to that too!

What I can suggest is identifying changesets where you uploaded a certain object with a certain tag, then user_changesets.pl from the revert scripts might be useful - you can then just grep for the tags and objects you want.

Another thing to perhaps look at is the OPL (“one per line”) that Osmium and related tools support - that allows you to combine tools to easily look for stuff.

1 Like
3

Maybe it will help a little with user_touched? just to take a quick look?
For a more in-depth analysis, and deleted data, I would look into working with sweden-internal.osh.pbf and PyOsmium But I can’t help much with that :pensive:

[out:xml][timeout:60];
{{geocodeArea:Sweden}}->.searchArea;
  way[surface](area.searchArea)(user_touched:emj);
out geom;
2 Likes
4

Ways where you added lesser used surface tags:

[out:json][timeout:25]; way(id:222366959,223271821,223271877,223271890,224352964,274257266,313539339,322682178,343403616,1195195384,1222744936,925587279,161254821,224353035,56213982); out geom;

Summary:
Surface tag: rocky;gravel, User count: 1, Taginfo count: 1, Percentage: 100.00%, User added tag: No
Surface tag: mud; gravel, User count: 1, Taginfo count: 1, Percentage: 100.00%, User added tag: Yes
Surface tag: rocky; gravel, User count: 1, Taginfo count: 1, Percentage: 100.00%, User added tag: Yes
Surface tag: rocky; gravel; tress, User count: 1, Taginfo count: 1, Percentage: 100.00%, User added tag: Yes
Surface tag: rocky;trees, User count: 1, Taginfo count: 1, Percentage: 100.00%, User added tag: Yes
Surface tag: Boardwalk,_Bedrock, User count: 1, Taginfo count: 1, Percentage: 100.00%, User added tag: No
Surface tag: gravel; trees, User count: 1, Taginfo count: 1, Percentage: 100.00%, User added tag: Yes
Surface tag: mud?, User count: 1, Taginfo count: 1, Percentage: 100.00%, User added tag: Yes
Surface tag: heavy_gravel;crossed_stones, User count: 1, Taginfo count: 1, Percentage: 100.00%, User added tag: Yes
Surface tag: gravel (perhaps), User count: 1, Taginfo count: 1, Percentage: 100.00%, User added tag: Yes
Surface tag: desire_line, User count: 1, Taginfo count: 1, Percentage: 100.00%, User added tag: Yes
Surface tag: sand,_mud, User count: 1, Taginfo count: 1, Percentage: 100.00%, User added tag: Yes
Surface tag: beach_sand, User count: 1, Taginfo count: 1, Percentage: 100.00%, User added tag: Yes
Surface tag: grund, User count: 1, Taginfo count: 8, Percentage: 12.50%, User added tag: No
Surface tag: dirt;mud, User count: 1, Taginfo count: 11, Percentage: 9.09%, User added tag: Yes
Surface tag: stones, User count: 2, Taginfo count: 355, Percentage: 0.56%, User added tag: Yes
Surface tag: rocky, User count: 7, Taginfo count: 1379, Percentage: 0.51%, User added tag: Not checked
Surface tag: steel, User count: 1, Taginfo count: 454, Percentage: 0.22%, User added tag: Yes
Surface tag: mud, User count: 47, Taginfo count: 27413, Percentage: 0.17%, User added tag: Not checked
Surface tag: stone, User count: 12, Taginfo count: 11985, Percentage: 0.10%, User added tag: Not checked
Surface tag: rock, User count: 20, Taginfo count: 22961, Percentage: 0.09%, User added tag: Not checked
Surface tag: artificial_turf, User count: 29, Taginfo count: 40104, Percentage: 0.07%, User added tag: Not checked
Surface tag: cement, User count: 1, Taginfo count: 2642, Percentage: 0.04%, User added tag: Not checked
Surface tag: fine_gravel, User count: 132, Taginfo count: 420494, Percentage: 0.03%, User added tag: Not checked
Surface tag: wood, User count: 61, Taginfo count: 220214, Percentage: 0.03%, User added tag: Not checked
Surface tag: pebblestone, User count: 32, Taginfo count: 127432, Percentage: 0.03%, User added tag: Not checked
Surface tag: sett, User count: 105, Taginfo count: 453267, Percentage: 0.02%, User added tag: Not checked
Surface tag: gravel, User count: 303, Taginfo count: 2130149, Percentage: 0.01%, User added tag: Not checked
Surface tag: metal, User count: 4, Taginfo count: 43651, Percentage: 0.01%, User added tag: Not checked
Surface tag: woodchips, User count: 1, Taginfo count: 10941, Percentage: 0.01%, User added tag: Not checked
Surface tag: unhewn_cobblestone, User count: 3, Taginfo count: 33457, Percentage: 0.01%, User added tag: Not checked
Surface tag: asphalt, User count: 2359, Taginfo count: 28228576, Percentage: 0.01%, User added tag: Not checked
Surface tag: sand, User count: 40, Taginfo count: 542600, Percentage: 0.01%, User added tag: Not checked
Surface tag: compacted, User count: 74, Taginfo count: 1070328, Percentage: 0.01%, User added tag: Not checked
Surface tag: dirt, User count: 105, Taginfo count: 1582010, Percentage: 0.01%, User added tag: Not checked
Surface tag: clay, User count: 2, Taginfo count: 34402, Percentage: 0.01%, User added tag: Not checked
Surface tag: concrete:plates, User count: 10, Taginfo count: 186039, Percentage: 0.01%, User added tag: Not checked
Surface tag: paving_stones, User count: 183, Taginfo count: 3483947, Percentage: 0.01%, User added tag: Not checked
Surface tag: grass_paver, User count: 2, Taginfo count: 43116, Percentage: 0.00%, User added tag: Not checked
Surface tag: grass, User count: 55, Taginfo count: 1205353, Percentage: 0.00%, User added tag: Not checked
Surface tag: paved, User count: 119, Taginfo count: 4077953, Percentage: 0.00%, User added tag: Not checked
Surface tag: unpaved, User count: 269, Taginfo count: 11665601, Percentage: 0.00%, User added tag: Not checked
Surface tag: ground, User count: 69, Taginfo count: 3263582, Percentage: 0.00%, User added tag: Not checked
Surface tag: concrete, User count: 50, Taginfo count: 3548446, Percentage: 0.00%, User added tag: Not checked
Surface tag: cobblestone, User count: 2, Taginfo count: 151365, Percentage: 0.00%, User added tag: Not checked
Surface tag: earth, User count: 1, Taginfo count: 151467, Percentage: 0.00%, User added tag: Not checked

1 Like
5

Some more lesser used tags/keys that you’ve added.

[out:json][timeout:25];
(
way[“leisure”=“pulkbacke”];
way[“note:building”=“tagging is iffy, this is a comercial, tv�ttstuga and apartments in one…”];
way[“start_date:surface”=“2015-11-01?”];
way[“name:2”=“Landegrensv�gen”];
way[“ramp”=“mud”];
way[“ramp:material”=“concrete”];
way[“ramp:railing”=“no”];
way[“date_start”=“1928”];
way[“built”=“1957?-1979?”];
way[“winter:ramp”=“no”];
way[“maxheight:above_water”=“12.9 m”];
way[“maxheight:marine”=“11.8 m”];
way[“ramp:type”=“stroller, one small with edges and one very big without”];
way[“service”=“tv�ttstuga”];
way[“prerental”=“yes”];
way[“villor”=“yes”];
way[“material”=“iron nad some pillars”];
way[“jetty”=“Canoe jetty”];
way[“winter”=“no sand”];
way[“height:floors”=“2”];
way[“swings”=“6”];
way[“mtb”=“maybe”];
way[“barrier:top”=“fence”];
way[“resource:sv”=“kalk”];
way[“wswings”=“yes”];
way[“material”=“landfill”];
way[“baby_swing”=“1”];
way[“excavator”=“1”];
way[“go_around”=“1”];
way[“swings”=“3”];
way[“firefighting”=“exercise tower”];
way[“building”=“dugouts”];
way[“date_start”=“1913-1916”];
way[“note:url”=“http://www.lansstyrelsen.se/stockholm/SiteCollectionDocuments/Sv/nyheter/2012/bm-beslut-solsater-2012.pdf”];
way[“sandbox”=“1”];
way[“start_date:construction”=“1886”];
way[“winter”=“ice”];
way[“kvarter”=“Bildf�nstret 1”];
way[“price:2008”=“815000SEK”];
way[“price:2010”=“1162000SEK”];
way[“water”=“beach/gravel/trees”];
way[“surface”=“mud; gravel”];
way[“wetland”=“grass soggy”];
way[“water”=“rocky beach”];
way[“water”=“shallow/grynnor”];
way[“water”=“something?”];
way[“isladn”=“kobbar”];
way[“water”=“land”];
way[“bottom”=“sand”];
way[“surface”=“rocky; gravel”];
way[“surface”=“rocky; gravel; tress”];
way[“surface”=“rocky;trees”];
way[“surface”=“gravel; trees”];
way[“water”=“very shallow”];
way[“water”=“seawater?”];
way[“url:map”=“http://grindawardshus.se/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/Svartvit-Grindakarta.pdf”];
way[“ref:url”=“http://www.linkoping.se/Global/Bygga%20och%20bo/Planer%20och%20byggprojekt/Byggprojekt/Hjulsbro_cg_vag_Stangan/Oversiktsritning_120_5_utan_racke.pdf?epslanguage=sv”];
way[“lot_name_ekonomiska”=“Dyngsk�r”];
way[“water”=“fj�rd”];
way[“renovation_date”=“2008”];
way[“shed”=“pump house”];
way[“ref:se:skolverket”=“87920455”];
way[“map:url”=“http://media.wix.com/ugd/72de80_3aa7737a122d46e3ad3b5a0756f98632.pdf”];
way[“parking”=“pre rent”];
way[“surface”=“mud?”];
way[“shed”=“carport f�r barnvagnar + waste”];
way[“water”=“sh”];
way[“ramp:note”=“you can drag a cargobike up here. but there’s no ramp”];
way[“ref:se:skolverket”=“99022046”];
way[“ramp:width”=“narrow”];
way[“spring_swings”=“yes”];
way[“ref:se:skolverket”=“82854505”];
way[“storage_size”=“900m�”];
way[“surface”=“heavy_gravel;crossed_stones”];
way[“landcover”=“boulders”];
way[“water”=“rocks”];
way[“ramp”=“unsure”];
way[“type”=“leaved woodland?”];
way[“water”=“stones”];
way[“building”=“shed;vedstuga”];
way[“surface”=“gravel (perhaps)”];
way[“bridge:type”=“probably just earth and a pipe under”];
way[“ref:se:skolverket”=“57184925”];
way[“barrier”=“wall/fence not sure”];
way[“landuse”=“human usage”];
way[“man_made”=“fishfarm”];
way[“railings”=“yes”];
way[“material”=“sand?”];
way[“type”=“walled up sand dune”];
way[“barrier”=“disused:fence”];
way[“observing”=“tower”];
way[“building”=“observing tower”];
way[“surface”=“desire_line”];
way[“ref:se:skolverket”=“56949296;85152591;85819857”];
way[“service”=“farm_access_road”];
way[“big_swing”=“yes”];
way[“building”=“benches for sports”];
way[“service”=“racetrack”];
way[“building”=“boat storage house”];
way[“manned_library”=“yes”];
way[“ref:se:skolverket”=“56949296”];
way[“intermittent”=“maybe…”];
way[“start_date:construction”=“2016-01-15”];
way[“bebyggelseregistret.raa:ref”=“21400000444659”];
way[“NOTE”=“tracks in snow out to the lake…”];
way[“previous:waterway”=“stream”];
way[“damage:structure:roof”=“light”];
way[“shed”=“pavilong”];
way[“building”=“bastu”];
way[“winter”=“DIY sand”];
way[“landuse”=“altan”];
way[“pier”=“badbrygga”];
way[“building”=“kollo”];
way[“building:historic”=“removed”];
way[“principal”=“Sigrid Stureg�rd”];
way[“shed:type”=“bicycle shed”];
way[“recycling:toxic_wood”=“yes”];
way[“building”=“root cellar”];
way[“building”=“dass”];
way[“surface”="sand,mud"];
way[“house”=“roof”];
way[“building”=“vinskydd_typ”];
way[“building”=“vindskydd typ”];
way[“surface”=“beach_sand”];
way[“shed”=“sailing mast storage”];
way[“shed”=“vedbod”];
way[“building”=“grovsopor”];
way[“building”=“garbage”];
way[“website_alt”=“https://forskola.stockholm/hitta-forskola/forskola/forskolan-raketen/”];
way[“ref:se:skolverket”=“39351914”];
way[“start_date:not_before”=“1975”];
way[“start_date:before”=“1960”];
way[“natural”=“subsea_reef”];
way[“type”=“roses”];
way[“ref:se:skolverket”=“52229866”];
way[“shed”=“dass”];
way[“natural”=“nothing”];
way[“moored”=“no”];
way[“water”=“not deep”];
way[“leisure”=“pulkabacke”];
way[“water”=“not_deep”];
way[“water”=“very_shallow”];
way[“water”=“islands”];
way[“water”=“shallow”];
way[“water”=“beach”];
way[“road_type”=“bymilj�v�g”];
way[“water”=“deep”];
way[“type”=“timmerv�g”];
way[“winter”=“yes”];
way[“steepness”=“pretty bad”];
way[“water”=“swimmingpool”];
way[“ice”=“winter”];
way[“built_date”=“1860”];
way[“running_water”=“no”];
way[“intermittent”=“probably…”];
way[“badstege”=“yes”];
way[“allee”=“yes”];
way[“recycling:sticks”=“yes”];
way[“recycling:toxic_waste”=“yes”];
way[“payment:membership”=“yes”];
way[“sewage”=“yes”];
way[“maxheight:above_water”=“15.5 m”];
way[“maxheight:marine”=“14.7 m”];
way[“swings”=“yes”];
way[“water”=“dry”];
way[“barrier”=“bush”];
way[“recycling:wellpapp”=“yes”];
way[“recycling:porslaine”=“yes”];
way[“service”=“garbage”];
way[“winter”=“no”];
way[“maxheight:above_water”=“12.8 m”];
way[“maxheight:marine”=“11.4 m”];
way[“swings”=“2”];
way[“barrier”=“natural”];
way[“recycling:gypsum”=“yes”];
way[“recycling:rest”=“yes”];
way[“round”=“yes”];
way[“man_made”=“ruins”];
way[“natural”=“shallow water”];
way[“building”=“subway_station”];
way[“building”=“social”];
way[“building”=“sawmill”];
way[“pontoon”=“yes”];
way[“surface”=“dirt;mud”];
way[“floors”=“2”];
way[“building”=“artwork”];
way[“cargobike”=“no”];
way[“man_made”=“structure”];
way[“tourism”=“historic”];
way[“material”=“rocks”];
way[“barrier”=“wire”];
way[“bathing”=“yes”];
way[“natural”=“lake”];
way[“barrier”=“stone_wall”];
way[“building”=“appartments”];
way[“man_made”=“retaining_wall”];
way[“landcover”=“rock”];
way[“pram”=“yes”];
way[“man_made”=“fountain”];
way[“material”=“natural_stones”];
way[“building”=“sauna”];
way[“wet”=“yes”];
way[“open”=“yes”];
way[“landuse”=“sport”];
way[“man_made”=“ditch”];
way[“leisure”=“sports”];
way[“free”=“no”];
way[“material”=“gravel”];
way[“man_made”=“mill”];
way[“kayak”=“yes”];
way[“leisure”=“paddling_pool”];
way[“building”=“power”];
way[“surface”=“stones”];
way[“amenity”=“scout_hut”];
way[“landuse”=“parking”];
way[“building”=“dugout”];
way[“payment:swish”=“yes”];
way[“building”=“lighthouse”];
way[“access”=“visitors”];
way[“surface”=“steel”];
way[“landuse”=“garden”];
);
way.(user_touched:emj);
out geom;