Fee: Double condition

Help and support
,
1

I’m looking for the correct fee tag for this situation:

There is a report of a parking space where fee is only charged if two conditions are met:

  • The first 2 hours are always free.
  • After that, fee is only charged Mon-Fri 7-19h and Sat 7-13h.

I’m unsure about the correct syntax.

This is no more than a blind guess:
fee=no +
fee:conditional=yes @ (stay > 2 hours & (Mo-Fr 07:00-19:00; Sa 07:00-13:00))

Can someone help?

3 Likes
2

Your proposal looks perfectly fine to me, fee=no covers most of the time with fee:conditional detailing the condition for which that is not true.

3

This is close, but the operator for a conjunction is AND or and, not &.

2 Likes
4

Nice thanks! Are nested round brackets ok?

So should I use
fee=no +
fee:conditional=yes @ (stay > 2 hours AND (Mo-Fr 07:00-19:00; Sa 07:00-13:00))

or rather
fee=no +
fee:conditional=yes @ (stay > 2 hours AND Mo-Fr 07:00-19:00); yes @ (stay > 2 hours AND Sa 07:00-13:00)
?

I want as many automated data consumers as possible to be able to understand the tag.

5

If you use Josm, Josm will automatically verify conditional restrictions. For the first variant it gives:

Does not match pattern ‘restriction @ condition’

The second form is accepted without problems.

I am not sure the first pattern is really wrong but I would go for the second pattern.

1 Like
6

Thanks.

However, in my experience it doesn’t always do good to blindly trust and follow the suggestions of these validators. :slight_smile:
I strive to understand what I’m doing.

2 Likes
7

Note that in the 1st example the outer parentheses and in the 2nd one all of them are unnecessary.

2 Likes
8

The wiki uses round brackets throughout, except if the condition is a single word. @SimonPoole are you saying the round brackets can be removed from almost all examples in the wiki articles for fee and conditional restrictions (except for those containing ;)?

9

Yes and this needs to be a complete sentence even if ‘yes’ is a complete answer.

2 Likes
10

I’m marking

fee=no +
fee:conditional=yes @ stay > 2 hours AND Mo-Fr 07:00-19:00; yes @ stay > 2 hours AND Sa 07:00-13:00

as solution.

Thanks @Minh_Nguyen @emvee and @SimonPoole

1 Like
11

There’s a lone closing bracket. QA will protest not being able to parse.

2 Likes
12

Corrected and this also needs to be a complete sentence.