Yes, disagreement is in the same vein as this poll Alpinist routes marked as footpaths - #39 by Hungerburg - now closed for good – 25 no vs 20 yes.
I feel like starting a new poll, with the cycleway/footway/promenade picture and asking, whether that should be tagged path. In the data it is a cycleway. I created the section from a split, with JOSM. I cannot remember if I got a warning.
I also feel like starting a Take 4 topic in this series. A mountain bike trail that I mapped with mtb=designated promptly got retagged bicycle=desginated. I have an idea about designation!