Walking route relations with large gaps: a list, if anyone fancies some

Hello all,

I run Adventure On Foot (adventureonfoot.co.uk), a free directory of UK walking routes built on OSM’s route relations, with credit to OpenStreetMap on every page. While checking each route against its publisher, we’ve found some long-distance relations that are only partly mapped, and a few tagging slips. I’m not a mapper myself, so I’m sharing the list in case it’s useful to anyone who knows these areas. Each line has the relation and what’s missing; the publisher pages say where the routes go (for checking, not for copying their maps).

Large gaps

  • Cross Cotswold Pathway, relation 934892: about 16 of 86 miles mapped (Banbury to around Long Compton)
  • Monnow Valley Walk, relation 7507181: only Skenfrith to Monmouth, about 7 of 40 miles
  • The Brenda Parker Way, relation 3091545: about 37 of 78 miles, in six pieces
  • Mid Wilts Way, relation 3343338: a gap of about 26 miles round Warminster, Bratton and Steeple Ashton
  • North Sperrins Way, relation 2665246: now about 7 miles (Dungiven to Swanns Bridge) of a 36-mile route
  • St Oswald’s Way, relation 4229903: two ways, about a tenth of a mile
  • The Saffron Trail, relation 13219978: about 1 mile of 70
  • The Danelaw Way, relation 1647400: a 2.6-mile stub near Corby Glen
  • Battlefields Trail, relation 3165973: stops about 3 miles short of Kineton
  • North Arden Heritage Trail, relation 1707659: about 8.6 miles in three pieces

National trails slightly off the official line

  • Offa’s Dyke Path, relation 9649: south of Monmouth the line runs up to about three quarters of a mile from the official route for 3.6 miles
  • Coast to Coast Path, relation 12145: near Kirkby Stephen the line runs about 1.5 miles from the official route for about 11 miles (the National Trail’s route may have been finalised since it was mapped)

Tagging

  • Notts Wolds Way, relation 6148106: operator misspells “Society” as “Scoiety”
  • Newtownabbey Way, relation 17636937: name spelt “Newtonabbey Way”
  • Sliabh Beagh Way, relation 1017125: tagged roundtrip=yes, but it’s a linear route

Thanks for all the work that goes into the map. Our pages pick up any fixes at our next monthly refresh.

Bam

1 Like

Thanks for flagging these issues. The tagging errors are easy “arm-chair” fixes that anyone could do. You’ve got an OSM account so you should be able to do these yourself if you wanted to. Though it can be a bit tricky making sure you’re editing the right thing with relations.

For the National Trails, are there GPX downloads available as OpenData? If so we could use them in OSM if we trusted that they did indeed match the on-the-ground signage.

For the other trails, I guess we’d need to either rely on local mappers to complete them, or (depending on the trail maintainer) could try asking for permission to use their trail info directly. This might be a bit tricky because of OS’s claim of IP rights over things drawn on OS Maps, but we may be able to work around that. If you were able to get permission to use any maps/data of the missing routes in OSM, I’m sure you’d find some mappers willing to help complete the OSM routes.

1 Like

The North Sperrins Way (and International Appalachian Trial) is in a mess at the moment because the local council, despite spending plenty of public money promoting it as a hiking trail, neglected to carry out their statutory duty to assert the public right of way… so a few months ago the landowners took the waymarked down and replaced it with No Trespassing signs and want to build a windfarm on it instead. E.g. see https://www.derrynow.com/news/campaign-group-concerned-over-attempts-to-erase-the-history-of-benbradagh-9141141

Thanks both.

Robert, on the National Trails, yes, Natural England publishes its National Trails lines as open data under the OGL (which I believe OSM accepts with attribution), and Natural Resources Wales does the same for the Welsh trails. Those are what we compared against, so the Offa’s Dyke and Coast to Coast differences above are against those lines. I’ll have a go at the three tagging fixes myself.

ramthelinefeed, thanks for the North Sperrins news, that’s useful and sad to hear. We’ve put a note about the access dispute over Benbradagh on our North Sperrins Way and Ulster Way pages, so nobody sets out expecting waymarks there. It’s prompted us to start checking every route for current closures and diversions too, so thank you.

Bam