Hello All,
I’ve sat down once again to check the list of trees supported by my UrbanEye3D plugin, and I discovered an absolutely astonishing thing.
It turns out that the leaf_type values needleleaved and broadleaved have NO definition whatsoever. None at all. The wiki does not refer to any generally accepted standard, nor does it provide its own.
Usually, needle-leaved plants are considered to be members of the Pinophyta division, specifically the seven extant families (‘Araucariaceae’, ‘Cephalotaxaceae’, ‘Cupressaceae’, ‘Pinaceae’, ‘Podocarpaceae’, ‘Sciadopityaceae’ and ‘Taxaceae’), but the OSM wiki says that this is by no means mandatory.
The wiki article Key:leaf_type says:
leaf_type=broadleaved – Broadleaved woody vegetation. Mainly angiosperms, but also some conifers.
leaf_type=needleleaved – Needleleaved woody vegetation. This category includes all plants with needle-like leaves, even if they are not conifers.
Roughly the same in Tag:leaf_type=needleleaved:
Needleleaved woody vegetation. This category includes all plants with needle-like leaves, even those that are not conifers, e.g. some acacias. This category is also often used for scale-like and awl-like leaves.
And all would be fine – anybody can tell a spruce from an oak – but these needle-leaved acacias have already appeared in OSM. Here is a list of what is already out there in the database:
| species | genus | family | leaf_type |
|---|---|---|---|
| Acacia aegyptiaca | Acacia | Fabaceae | needleleaved |
| Acacia nilotica | Acacia | Fabaceae | needleleaved |
| Acacia peuce | Acacia | Fabaceae | needleleaved |
| Archontophoenix cunninghamiana | Archontophoenix | Arecaceae | needleleaved |
| Casuarina cunninghamiana | Casuarina | Casuarinaceae | needleleaved |
| Casuarina equisetifolia | Casuarina | Casuarinaceae | needleleaved |
| Cordyline banksii | Cordyline | Asparagaceae | needleleaved |
| Hyophorbe lagenicaulis | Hyophorbe | Arecaceae | needleleaved |
| Mauritia flexuosa | Mauritia | Arecaceae | needleleaved |
| Pandanus utilis | Pandanus | Pandanaceae | needleleaved |
| Vachellia nilotica | Vachellia | Fabaceae | needleleaved |
| Afrocarpus gracilior | Afrocarpus | Podocarpaceae | broadleaved |
| Agathis australis | Agathis | Araucariaceae | broadleaved |
And here too we find Agathis australis, the kauri – a most ancient conifer that outlived the dinosaurs – is classified as broadleaved.
Casuarina cunninghamiana – even in the curated list it’s marked needleleaved, despite obviously being an angiosperm.
The question is, does any of this make sense? Has anyone seen a definition in any book that classifies broadleaved vs needleleaved based on leaf shape, e.g., if the ratio of length to width is greater than 10, then it’s broadleaved, otherwise needleleaved?
Or maybe it’s all nonsense, and for any practical purpose (e.g. for rendering in UrbanEye3D) it is enough to consider a plant needleleaved if it belongs to the Pinophyta division, and all the rest as broadleaved.
I would appreciate any thoughts on this matter.
Best regards,
Zkir


