Selber Bot-Verursacher neue Aktion: "fixing unusual playground values with a clear replacement"

Guten Abend,

Neuer Bot, …nächste Runde…

  • was wird da gemacht?
  • wo wurde es disskutiert?
  • Wo wurde es genehmigt?

[Edit] auch hier erwarte ich von @Mateusz_Konieczny direkt eine Beantwortung zunächst meiner drei Fragen! Weitere könnern folgen! /Edit]

Sven

Alle Fragen sind in den Links im changeset beantwortet.

8 Likes

@streckenkundler

Ich sehe diese (neue) Runde folgendermaßen:

OSM ist eine Datenbank. @Mateusz_Konieczny sucht nach offensichtlichen Tippfehlern und da sich so etwas in der Welt der Computer seit sehr langer Zeit nun einmal automatisieren lässt, automatisiert er diesen Vorgang in sehr engen Bahnen.

Alles daran ist sauber in den Metadaten der Änderung dokumentiert.

7 Likes

this edit changed Node History: 4290358711 | OpenStreetMap

specifically it changed playground=rotating-seesaw to playground=rotating_seesaw

you can check by going to Changeset: 177778720 | OpenStreetMap and looking on list of edited objects, listed at bottom of the sidebar when you open changeset

in this case changeset contains one object and it looks like this:

screen-2026-01-28-07-08-04

on Node: 4290358711 | OpenStreetMap page you can press history link

to obtain Node History: 4290358711 | OpenStreetMap overview, and look how tags/position changed (note: relation membership is sadly not shown on history pages, but in this edit relations were not edited, so it should not be a problem).

You can also look for example at achavi - Augmented OSM Change Viewer  [attic]

which shows changes to tags and geometries in readable format. Sometimes fails for large or just made edits, but often works.


In such case discussion before edits is not needed, see advise given at Define, check and (automated) correct string-values for the tag "colour" (for buildings, ...) - #12 by SomeoneElse and Automated Edits code of conduct - OpenStreetMap Wiki - this is linked from changeset tags

is there some reason why you have not looked at them before starting a new thread?


(it is possible to argue that such edit is bad for reasons, and there are possible failure modes*, or that linked content is not relevant, maybe bot edit policy should be changed, but questions were about either quite basic use of OSM interface or about already answered questions so I answered those)

*and yes, human editing also has failure modes


In the future, please read changeset comment and changeset tags before bothering me or other OSM contributors.

12 Likes