Thank you Kevbold for joining this discussion. This thread mainly focuses on the edit war in Ngawi area, so no worries about Palangka Raya.
Bagaimana kesimpulan dari diskusi kita sejauh ini? Terminologi jalan untuk OSM saat ini memang tidak harus kaku mengikuti regulasi pemerintah, tetapi tanpa adanya acuan baku, klasifikasi jalan berisiko menjadi subjektif.
@Gaung Tebono, jika ada hal yang belum jelas terkait deskripsi penandaan jalan di Indonesia, mari kita diskusikan lebih mendalam di sini.
Perlu diingat bahwa fokus diskusi di forum ini adalah atribut highway=*, bukan topik lainnya.
English
What is the conclusion of our discussion so far? While OSM road terminology does not strictly have to follow government regulations, the lack of a standardized reference risks making classifications subjective.
@Gaung_Tebono, if anything remains unclear regarding the road tagging descriptions in Indonesia Wiki, please feel free to discuss it further here first.
Please keep in mind that the focus of this forum is solely on the highway=* attribute, not other topics.
1 Like
Since there is no further comment from him, I think we may stick with existing guideline for now. In the meantime, there are two new contributors that reverted back woodpeck’s edit in Ngawi, like this one.
Saya mengirimi mereka pesan pribadi kemarin. Berdasarkan informasi yang mereka berikan, tidak ada satupun yang merupakan alt account Gaung Tebono.
English
I sent them a private message yesterday. Based on the information they provided, none of them are alt accounts of Gaung Tebono.
1 Like
@Gaung_Tebono Welcome back to OSM. I saw your road classification edits in Yogyakarta and Solo, but I cannot find your source or justification about those edits. May explain?