[RFC] Tagging proposal for transfer hoists

Hi there,

Inspired by a recent article in Danish media, I have started tagging public toilets that have hoists to aid transfers between a wheelchair and a toilet, changing table, bed, or other facility. These could also be relevant for places like hotels, medical facilities, and other places where wheelchair users might need a hoist to transfer to and from their wheelchair.

There is currently a proposed tag changing_table:hoist, via the On Wheels app, though it does not seem to have been used yet.

My suggestion is tagging them as follows:

Main tag: hoist=yes/no

Possible use with prefixes:

  • Accessible toilets: toilets:wheelchair:hoist=yes
  • Hotel rooms: wheelchair:hoist=yes on the hotel node, or perhaps rooms:wheelchair:hoist=yes, or simply hoist=yes
    (I am unsure how that’s best represented, as some hotels will have rooms with ceiling mounted hoists, while others have a mobile hoist available which can be moved into any accessible room)
  • Changing table: changing_table:hoist=yes (as proposed via the On Wheels app)
  • Others?

And it might be relevant to have some further keys describing the provided hoist:

Key Meaning Values
hoist:type The type of hoist available, the main types being ceiling-mounted and mobile hoists. ceiling, mobile, others?
hoist:sling Whether a sling is provided for the hoist, or users need to bring their own (this should maybe be sling_provided instead, for clarity?) yes, no

As an example, I have tagged the accessible toilet at Nørreport Station in Copenhagen, Denmark.
That toilet has a hoist for transfer onto the toilet, but does not have an adult changing table, demonstrating a use case that cannot appropriately be described using changing_table:hoist=*.
For reference, photos and a description of the toilet are available on the God Adgang website.

Edit:

Another possible approach would be to always use wheelchair:hoist=* as the main tag, rather than hoist=*, since transfer hoists are specifically an accessibility aid for people who require assisted transfers.

I ran out of links due to being a new user, so here is the node for the toilet at Nørreport Station: Node: 3303123977 | OpenStreetMap

OSM has this in UK, which needs to be improved

wheelchair:*= is mostly a misunderstanding on how it should be structured. hoist:wheelchair= should be used if needed, but hoist= can indeed be used. Mobiles ones can be hoist:portable=yes , with ramp:portable= and platform_lift:portable= now.

That’s a good point. I think my reasoning for the prefixes were for when accessible bathrooms are located within a node containing multiple bathrooms. I can see that was something that was discussed with the grab_rails tag.

One thing however is that, I don’t personally use hoists, and have almost certainly made some assumptions about them, that would leave the information for users incomplete. The best thing would be getting some input from people who actually use hoists.

I’m thinking stuff like:

  • Are there certain types of hoists that are not usable for some people? Maybe some can only use ceiling mounted ones.
  • Are the slings always universally compatible, or should there be some sort of key specifying the compatible sling systems?
  • Should load rating be specified as well?
  • Perhaps whether they can be operated independently (I presume some are motorised like gantry cranes)?
  • Probably other stuff I haven’t even thought of.

I’ll try to reach out in my own network and see if anyone has relevant experience as a user or carer. I’d also like to figure out what information is actually most important, so we don’t end up adding a bunch of details that nobody really needs or that mappers are unlikely to fill in.

1 Like