[RFC] Feature Proposal - Add brt=yes/no to route=bus to mark BRT lines

After reading through all replies I want to say thank you for the fruitful discussion. I see some disagreement, and maybe it is too big to reach the 75% mark to reach a consensus. But maybe it is not.

I think the frequency of a bus line can be mapped with interval.

What does not — to my knowledge — have a tagging in OSM is the speed of the vehicles (buses)**. I dont mean maxspeed, but average speed including (scheduled) stops, stops at traffic signals and stops/slower movement due to other traffic (mainly cars).

If regular stops are short (few seconds) and traffic lights and (car) traffic do not slow down, then the bus has a special quality which I would like to be able to map.

I am not sure, how this quality shall be named. Maybe the native speakers can help. My ideas are

  • undisturbed_vehicle_flow=yes
  • independent_vehicle_flow=yes
  • stopping_only_at_bus_stops=yes
  • no_stopping_between_bus_stops=yes

**Bus only ways or lanes give a hint about it, but I know many buses with such lanes still being slow because they wait at red lights all the time. On the other hand, when a street has almost no car traffic, or car traffic is kept out of the buses’ way through intelligent traffic signals, a bus only way is not needed at some places to reach the quality.

1 Like