Review request: Mapping all 18 golf holes at The Hawthorns in Fishers, Indiana

I’d like feedback on adding numbered tee-to-green routes for all 18 holes at The Hawthorns Golf & Country Club in Fishers, Indiana.

I have an AI-assisted simulator draft as a starting point. The tee anchors and green aim points are approximate, so I plan to verify each route against OSM-permitted imagery or on-the-ground observations before publishing.

My proposed scope for this review is the hole routes, using golf=hole, ref=* for the hole number, and par=* where verified. Would local mappers prefer individually reviewed edits in iD, or should I prepare a formal import proposal for any part of this work? I’d also welcome feedback from anyone familiar with the course. This is my home course so it should be accurate.

should I add the edits draft here?

Is the scope just this golf course? It would be faster to review them by hand than to write a proposal if that is the case.

Also, it seems like your tool is struggling with tee positions. Hole 1 looks like you’re starting in the woods. It might be worth it to draw the lines yourself

2 Likes

This is a small enough scope that the Mechanized Edits policy shouldn’t apply. Using software to do this (which does trigger the policy) is a mistake.

Try using this software instead:

I will give that a shot,

Thanks!