PTNA: news for Public Transport Network Analysis

General talk
, ,
488

Yesterday, I added a new check to ptna for the analysis of public-transport data of osm

  • ‘roundtrip’ is set / not set on a route relation
    • = ‘yes’ but first and last platform stops are not the same (same OSM ID) => error
    • = ‘no’ but first and last platform stops are the same (same OSM ID) => error
    • not set and first and last platform stops are the same (same OSM ID) => note

I’ve seen at least one situation, where

  • first and last platforms are not the same but in the same bus station and where
  • ‘roundtrip’ = ‘yes’

What are your thoughts on this: is this right or wrong?

The check was introduced based on a suggestion by @donmac703

1 Like