Proposed Tags for Indonesian-specific Features / Usulan Tag untuk Fitur Khusus Indonesia

Communities Indonesia
1

Halo kawan-kawan POI,

Saya beberapa kali menemukan objek khas Indonesia yang belum terakomodasi dengan baik oleh standar tagging global, berikut adalah daftar objeknya:
~
I have several times found typical Indonesian objects that have not been properly accommodated by global tagging standards, here is a list of the objects:

  1. Gapura
    Karakteristik: Berada di jalan masuk lingkungan, tidak memiliki daun pintu fisik, dan tidak menghalangi akses jalan. Berbeda dengan candi bentar yang diperuntukkan untuk kawasan istana atau tempat ibadah hindu.
    ~
    Characteristics: Located at the entrance to the neighborhood, does not have a physical door, and does not block road access. This is different from the candi bentar which is intended for palace areas or Hindu places of worship.
    ~
    Saran tag/Proposed tag:
    access=yes + door=no + entrance=main
    man_made=ceremonial_gate + ceremonial_gate=gapura

Kadang tidak ada atap/Sometimes there is no roof::

  1. Pertamini / Pertashop / Kios Bensin Eceran
    Karakteristik: Kios bahan bakar skala kecil/rumahan, bukan SPBU besar; amenity=fuel standar sering kali menyesatkan karena ekspektasi fasilitas SPBU standar.
    ~
    Characteristics: Small-scale/home-based fuel kiosks, not large gas stations; The standard amenity=fuel is often misleading because of the expectation of standard gas station amenities.
    ~
    ada saran tag?/any tag suggestions?
  1. Pos Ronda / Pos Kamling
    Saat ini menggunakan tag yang sering digunakan adalah amenity=shelter atau building=yes dengan selalu pemberian nama name=Pos Ronda, namun fungsi sosial dan fungsi keamanannya belum terwakili.
    ~
    Currently, the tags that are often used are amenity=shelter or building=yes, always giving the name name=Pos Ronda, but their social and security functions have not been represented.
    ~
    ada saran tag?/any tag suggestions?

sedang_1520220470IMG_20180304_100652
sedang_1520220470IMG_20180304_1006521366×768 107 KB

https://desadengok.gunungkidulkab.go.id/assets/files/artikel/sedang_1558159603IMG_20190518_090302.jpg
https://desasemanu.gunungkidulkab.go.id/assets/files/artikel/sedang_1580653318WhatsApp%20Image%202020-02-02%20at%2005.37.02.jpeg

Apakah ada lagi objek khas Indonesia?

2

Hi,

There are some similar concepts in other places that have been documented. You might look at how they are used and what difficulties might arise.

Tag:man_made=ceremonial_gate - OpenStreetMap Wiki

Tag:historic=city_gate - OpenStreetMap Wiki

Key:barrier - OpenStreetMap Wiki

Depending on size, some of the entrances that you show might need to be also tagged with barrier=height_restrictor and maxheight=* to help prevent tall vehicles hitting them. Alternatively add maxheight=* to the road under the entrance.

3

Thank you for the insightful feedback. man_made=ceremonial_gate is indeed a great match for these structures. Also, adding maxheight=* (or a height restrictor tag where applicable) is an excellent point for taller vehicles. Tagging them as man_made=ceremonial_gate + ceremonial_gate=gapura seems like the best approach.