Proposed imports of website tags for Europabank, based on ATP first-party data (just 7 <s>11</s> of them)

Communities België / Belgique / Belgien (Belgium)
1

I matched OpenStreetMap and All the Places datasets.

Several matching rules were used to get set of cases where matches are very confident.

In some cases OSM has no website tag or one leading to the main page, while ATP has POI-specific one.

I propose to import them and repeat import if more matches would appear, for Europabank brand.

The tricky part is that due to my mistake import mostly already happened ( Sorry for a bot edit escaping its supposed borders (adding website tags) ) - I am sorry for that, that is obviously a wrong order.

If import will be rejected or not accepted, I will revert all such edits.

If import will be accepted I will post changeset comments on relevant changesets explaining that it was in the end reviewed and accepted. And make future edits based on new matches, once they will be found. This is especially likely for newly opened shops.

OSM objects were edited / will be edited only if

  • there is no website and contact:website tags
  • or these tags link main page rather than specific store page
  • or these links redirect to a found website address

Data is taken by ATP project from their website, see alltheplaces/locations/spiders/europabank_be.py at 35dc669befd05ec065eb1d30dafec2305953ca4d · alltheplaces/alltheplaces · GitHub

Affected objects are

Mateusz Konieczny - bot account - ATP import | OpenStreetMap already imports website for Poland in general and did some proper imports on USA. Editing is currently suspended as I want to cleanup one way or another this border-crossing imports. It took me few months before I had free time to write code necessary for cleanup, but I can now identify impacted areas. This thread is the next step for cleanup, some other countries were also affected and will be also handled.

I have a decent experience with bot edits, see Mechanical Edits/Mateusz Konieczny - bot account - OpenStreetMap Wiki

2

Also, would you be fine with catchall proposal for such ATP-based imports of website in Belgium for other cases where ATP is using first-party data?

Or would you prefer to do it brand-by-brand?

3

If this are only 7 nodes (although the title says 11) I think it is hardly needed to discuss it.

The Belgium community is not that active on this forum, there is more activity on:

https://matrix.to/#/#osmbe:matrix.org

4

Generally doing these brand by brand seems to be the most cautious approach. The import is fine, 7 poi’s is reasonable. If you want more feedback, you’d be better off proposing the import in the matrix channel suggested above.

1 Like
5

posted also there

6

wiki page is up at Mechanical Edits/Mateusz Konieczny - bot account/import Europabank websites in Belgium from ATP - OpenStreetMap Wiki

1 Like