[Poll] How would you tag this rock path surface?

Came across this image on Wikimedia Commons and wasn’t sure which surface tag fits best:


Photo: David Medcalf, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

It’s not clear whether the stones were deliberately placed. Either way, two surface tags come to mind:

  • surface=rock: the wiki notes it “is applicable both in some cases of man-made surfaces of trails and in cases where trail goes across exposed bare rock.”
  • surface=stepping_stones: defined as “individually placed stones set at regular intervals for stepping from one to the next, to avoid walking on the ground below. Commonly used for river or creek crossings, muddy crossings, or areas to preserve the grass from being trampled.”

What would you tag this as in the field?

  • surface=rock
  • surface=stepping_stones
  • Neither (comment below)
0 voters

I used surface=unhewn_cobblestone for such surfaces in past

1 Like

surface=rock only because I try to avoid using infrequently used tag values. Much more important is to tag sac_scale=mountain_hiking or maybe smoothness=horrible if the way is likely to be used by wheeled vehicles (as long as it’s firm, I don’t care much what the surface under my feet is called)

1 Like

surface=unhewn_cobblestone could make sense for deliberately placed cobble-sized stones, but here I am seeing very large, boulder-sized rocks.

3 Likes

The section shown in the photo looks very much like an example of surface=rock + highway=steps.

6 Likes

surface=rock + highway=steps was my first thought too.

highway=path + surface=stepping_stones also feels reasonable, although stepping stones on an incline basically sounds like the definition of (rudimentary) steps!

3 Likes