On NCN Route 13 - OSM vs. Sustrans vs. local singage

A question for the experts on cycleways and their statuses.

Following completion of the Tideway Tunnel, the thameside footpath between King Edward Memorial Park and Narrow Street, London is now reopened.

At least some of this footpath is part of NCN national cycle route 13. The OSM relation and the Sustrans map disagree about how much of it is part of Route 13.

Some of this footpath is clearly signed with cycling forbidden signs. Including parts that are in Route 13, by either definition.

Either OSM is wrong, Sustrans is wrong, Route 13 is badly defined, the local signage is wrong or something. Which is most likely ,and what can be done? [1]

Segments signed cycling forbidden (yesterday):

  1. Way: 193417359 | OpenStreetMap
  2. Way: 1157275651 | OpenStreetMap
  3. Way: 1157275655 | OpenStreetMap

Segments part of OSM relation 8069487 (NCN Route 13):
3. Way: 1157275655 | OpenStreetMap
4. Way: 193417360 | OpenStreetMap
5. Way: 634374860 | OpenStreetMap (this segment has an actual NCN 13 sign on it)
On OSM Route 13, it diverts to The Highway via w513371055 instead of carrying on along the river.

Segments part of NCN Route 13 according to Sustrans/Walk Wheel Cycle Trust:

  1. Way: 193417359 | OpenStreetMap
  2. Way: 1157275651 | OpenStreetMap
  3. Way: 1157275655 | OpenStreetMap
  4. Way: 193417360 | OpenStreetMap
  5. Way: 634374860 | OpenStreetMap (this segment has an actual NCN 13 sign on it)

  1. (Local residents (or someone) are very partial to painting over Thames Path signs that relate to w8069482 and deploying large planters to hide (but not actually block) the way through, so it could be that the no cycling signs are Bad and Wrong.) ↩︎

2 Likes

Sustrans publish what they claim to be their National Cycle Network routes here: Detailed maps & routes to explore across the UK | OS Maps

So I guess that counts as the ‘official’ route. (Personally speaking I have often spotted what appear to be mistakes on their mapping, and seldom have they ever corrected them if I’ve emailed them about it… this includes things like Sustrans claiming there’s a traffic free route on a cycle path, where in reality it’s a pavement where cycling ain’t permitted)

Metal NCN route signs are generally put up by the highway authority - so typically that’s the local Council, London borough, or TfL. These various bodies presumeably originally were told by Sustrans where the routes where intended to go. But sometimes they put them up in the wrong places. Or they end up getting bashed about and pointing the wrong way. Or Sustrans change or cancel the route, but the Highway Authority doesn’t change the signage on the ground.

Stickered route signs have generally been put up by enthusiastic Sustrans voltuneers, again, one presumes, following Sustrans’ directions. Occasionally these will have been stuck up wrong, or Sustrans have subsequently changed the route and nobody’s amended the stickers.

So, um, in summary, I think we have to accept that NCN routes are wherever Sustrans say they are. But because Sustrans don’t generally own the on-the-ground signage or tidy up their old stickers, discrepancies can not infrequently be observed on the ground.

The situation is often worse in London because TfL keeps hustling London boroughs into newly re-branded cycle schemes every few years (London Cycle Network, Cycle Superhighways, Greenways, Quietways, 2012 Olympics Routes, Cycleways, …) and so the mounting incoherence of those is what takes the bulk of borough’s focus when it comes to waymarking…

1 Like

As an example, with this bit: Way: 193417359 | OpenStreetMap
It’s a while since I cycled there but if I remember right the eastern end of that segment (where it rejoins the road) was always a ridiculous squeeze past big flower pots? I suspect that bit of river frontage is privately owned but Sustrans just decided to declare it was a national cycle network route anyways, but every now and again the landowner or tenants decide to declare it isn’t. And so there’s a right of way dispute and Sustrans never make an effort to resolve it and instead just keep claiming it as part of their charitable achievements /sighs/. A similar situation has pertained for years on NCN1 as it traverses the Isle of Dogs, with the Canary Wharf freeholders putting up cycle barriers, no cycling signs and so on.

Yes, the east end (round Keepier Wharf) is the bit I refer to in the footnote to paragraph 5.

Thanks for the info, it all makes sense. What would you do in this situation? Edit the route according to Sustrans, but leave the relevant bits as bicycles=no?

:sweat_smile: I dunno, to be honest - for many years I tried hard to edit London’s cycle routes to help them make sense, which sometimes meant pragmatically accepting that the ‘authoritative’ data sources (such as Sustrans’ NCN map, or TfL’s latest bizarre mapping) and the dodgy signage on the ground just had irreconcilable errors, and so for those bits I’d try to tag the route as an actual human cyclist on the ground would actually cycle them, which might mean a bit of interpollation. I guess my rationale was along the lines of ‘This is a mostly way-marked recreational cycle route that is 10 or 20 odd miles long, and if someone not unreasonably wants to spend an afternoon trying to cycle it, OSM’s tagging may as well help them get from one end of it to the other in one piece as best as it can’.
But by now I’ve probably got to the point of declaring ‘this is just bollocks’ and brutally de-tagging bits which only exist in Sustrans’ mind. :sweat_smile: Other editors may well take a different view, as I have done myself in simpler gentler times :grinning_face_with_smiling_eyes:

I’ve suggested this in at least one of the other Sustrans topics, but where things are a mess I’d try and map the individual signs with a role that indicates whether they’re supposed to be on the route (not in brackets) or leading to the route (in brackets). Doing that will likely reveal some obvious outliers but it will help future mappers - likely telling future solvers of a jigsaw puzzle that the picture on the box is wrong!

(in that picture “green” are signs that are supposed to be on the route and “orange” are “leading to…”)

Yes I adopted the exact same approach, micromapping signage where possible. I felt this was particularly useful with ‘unnumbered’ London Cycle Network routes, where you’d be following a trail of blue signs saying ‘Croydon’ or ‘Crystal Palace’ or whatever (I swear I found more than one instance where the only explanation I could offer for the location of these signs was that the contractor installing them had had their map help upside down, with south at the top :face_with_hand_over_mouth:)