julcnx
(julcnx)
September 19, 2024, 3:47am
15
flohoff:
If its a legal issue - e.g. a “motorcycleway” with the signage in that thread its a motorcar=no motorcycle=designated - Its still a residential as its purpose is to make a residential area accessible.
But dont invent new road types which are 100% identical to other road types, just imply some access tagging.
First off, dedicated ways for motorcycles are not found in residential ways, and again there is no proposal yet. Second, you categorically reject new tags but never respond to the flaws in your reasoning:
That last paragraph lost me… Are you saying we shouldn’t create any new top-level tags (hello highway=busway) just because we’re afraid they’ll stray from their intended use?
Also, it seems like you missed the highway=motorcycleway proposal – probably because it doesn’t exist yet
Following your logic, I might as well start a proposal to deprecate highway=footway/cycleway/path/bridleway/pedestrian and have mappers “stick to physical aspects” together with highway=residential/service/tra…