Import: Bus stops from GTFS

[skyper]

@NeatNit

I get the impression that it’s designed for much smaller GTFS feeds like a single city, whereas Israel has a single giant GTFS feed for the entire country. I hope PTNA will be able to handle that gracefully. I guess the maintainer of PTNA will be able to answer that

Switzerland and the Netherlands have also only one single GTFS feed. So this should not be a problem.
The analysis is broken down into tariff zones but there are pages for complete countries like all railway routes in Germany.

@NeatNit

@skyper

I am not sure if gtfs:stop_id=* + gtfs:feed=IL-MOT or gtfs:stop_id:IL-MOT=* is the better approach.

The GTFS wiki page is definitive about preferring the latter, see Interpretation of deprecated gtfs:feed=* and other “Interpretation of deprecated” subsections on the page. It seems this info was added in March 2024 with the comment “Incorporate approved proposal GTFS tagging standard” so I think it’s up to date.

Well the proposal tried to solve the situation for several GTFS feeds and stop ids for one object. It had only a few votes and even the author back-paddled a bit as can be read from [RFC] Feature Proposal - GTFS Tagging standard - #32 by ToniE onward.