There’s a “copy” option (which actually seems to mean “duplicate”)
(and it only seems to be available intermittently)
but there seems to be no “copy tags” option?
If you switch to the raw tags view in the editing pane you can select and copy all the tags at once.
Isn’t that the definition of copying ![]()
So that’s:
Create the node to copy to.
Click on something random in the list of features so that the node has some tags on it (it doesn’t seem to work unless you do)
Click on the node to copy from.
Scroll down and press the text button:
Click in the field, control A, control C
Click on the thing to copy to
Click in the field and then control V
That’s about 8 actions I think. Compare with Potlatch which is “click on the thing to copy from, click on the thing to copy to, press ‘r’”.
Pretty much. Josm has the same feature as potlatch (shift+R) to copy tags (requires the utilsplugin2 plugin). iD has never been known for having efficient workflows.
this one will be remembered and does not need to be repeated
if you copy crossing node with all its tags I would just copy crossing node
that allows you to do: paste free floating node, grab it and move onto road
or more specifically, when entire feature is within current viewpoint
From experience, you don’t need entire feature, but around 3/4. And, as you can’t zoom out too much in ID, you can’t change geometry of large features with ID.
you can’t change geometry of large features with ID.
I am pretty sure you can. Do you mean that rotation etc features operating on the entire object are disabled when only part is shown?
It’s not really that bad. If you go the other way round, you have:
Change the Tags box to “text” (only once needed)
By doing so you can reduce the actions from 8 to 4 (plus the first step which is only necessary once).
but there seems to be no “copy tags” option?
See also Add "copy tags" keyboard shortcut · Issue #11674 · openstreetmap/iD · GitHub (that proposed to add copy tags but in place that would add extra complexity without cutting down much on number of operations needed - and I closed it recently as rejected) and Add "copy tags" keyboard shortcut · Issue #11674 · openstreetmap/iD · GitHub specifically
Isn’t that the only part that is missing currently? I don’t immediately see why we’d need a special Copy Tags operation, when the tags are already implicitly included in the existing copy buffer as part of the copied feature. If we were to add a new operation Paste Tags, it could just take the tags from there and merge it onto the current feature. So the workflow would be just:
- select first feature
- right click → copy (or Ctrl C)
- select second feature
- right click → paste tags (or something like Ctrl Shift V)
though AFAIK there is no issue at Issues · openstreetmap/iD · GitHub for such “paste tags” feature.
Ideally when opened it would propose specifically how it should behave (should it be just shortcut? button? If button then where? How it should behave when some tags are already present? Should it replace existing ones? Only conflicting ones? Maybe warn user? If warn - how?)
Or maybe #11674 as proposed would be actually substantial improvement?