Community Review New MapRoulette challenge: United Kingdom – Accuracy Review of Toll-Related Features

Hello everyone,

I’d like to share a small MapRoulette challenge for community review: United Kingdom – Accuracy Review of Toll-Related Features – 9 tasks

The challenge is undiscoverable in MapRoulette which ensure that it can be accessed only via the direct link shared in this consulation.

The challenge focuses on toll-related features in OSM that may need to be added, updated, removed, or marked as no longer operational. A particular focus is ensuring the correct distinction between toll booths (barrier=toll_booth) and free-flow toll gantries (highway=toll_gantry), helping accurate representation, improving routing and toll-approaching warnings.

The tasks were created through a manual review by TomTom local mappers. Where available, primary sources were national toll operators and concessionaires’ data. Additional sources are existing OSM data, street-level imagery, operator information, and other available evidence. Each task includes a suggested action and tagging proposal. It is provided to support assessment but, the final verification would independently rely also on local knowledge, imagery and relevant OSM wiki guidance for every case before making any edits.

We welcome all comments and suggestions and are happy to adjust the challenge where appropriate based on community feedback. Unless concerns are identified or the challenge is already completed, we plan to begin working on the challenge 15 days from the date of this post.

Thank you for your review and feedback,

Priscilla - TomTom

Just wanted to briefly bring this challenge back to visibility. If anyone has feedback, suggestions, or local insights, please let me know.

A couple of of thoughts - the description on the front page is:

The goal:

At TomTom, we proudly support OpenStreetMap (OSM) communities around the world in the mission to create a more accurate and usable map for all.

As part of this challenge, we’re reviewing toll-related features in OpenStreetMap to identify records that need be updated, removed, added, or marked as non-operational. The focus includes particular attention to distinguishing toll booths, where drivers may need to stop, from free-flow toll gantries, where they may need to slow down, and correcting features that do not represent road tolls. Correct positioning and classification reduce phantom toll warnings, incorrect charging assumptions, and misleading guidance while supporting safer speed management and improving routing, navigation, and the representation of real-world road infrastructure.

How were the tasks in the challenge created?

The tasks were created through a systematic review of the complete set of toll-related features on OSM. TomTom’s local experts manually classified every record as Correct, Update, Remove, Out of business, or Create and recorded any required corrections to the name, category, coordinates, and operator. Reviews prioritized national toll authorities and concessionaires; where no single authoritative source exists, experts combined operator information, OSM tags, available street-level imagery, and local knowledge.

Please note that some tasks may no longer require edits. If the issues have already been addressed by other contributors, feel free to mark the task as “Already Fixed”. If you think that the issue does not require a fix, and is correct as it is, please mark the task as “Not an Issue”.

Contact us!

At TomTom, we prioritize quality and usability in the challenges we share and value your feedback. If you have any input regarding this challenge or any others, feel free to reach out to us through the “Get In Touch” button below, local forums, or by emailing OSM@tomtom.com.

For more information on other TomTom challenges, visit our open GitHub repository or our OSM Wiki page.

Do you think perhaps that could benefit from a few fewer words?

A detected item is:

Instructions

Suggested action: Create new POI

Latitude: → 53.35699

Longitude: → -2.72166

You Should:

Select your preferred editor from the drop-down list in "Completion” box below, then click “Edit”.   

Use the most appropriate imagery, ground truth/street view and/or your local knowledge to verify the presence of the toll-related features. You can refer to the task-specific information provided above.

Review the object and country specific wiki pages for any nuances or exceptions you should be aware of.

a. https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:toll

b. https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:highway%3Dtoll_gantry

c. https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:barrier%3Dtoll_booth

d. https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:barrier

Refer to the suggested location and tags below. You can copy and paste the tags directly into the editor if you choose to. If the value is listed as empty or no change, that means there is no suggestion for this task and the key should be omitted.

highway=toll_gantry

name = Mersey Gateway Bridge Toll Gantry

operator = Merseyflow

fee = yes

fee:conditional = empty

charge:motorcycle = empty

charge:motorcar = £2.40

charge:hgv = empty

charge:goods = empty

Review your edit and ensure that it makes sense from both technical (i.e. tagging, classification, etc.) and practical (i.e. connectivity, navigability, turn restrictions, etc.) perspectives.

Provide an informative and concise changeset comment when uploading your edits.

Upload your edits in OSM.    

Select “I fixed it!” status for the edit made.    

If for some reason a map edit is not necessary, or possible, choose one of the following statuses:

“Already fixed” – If the suggested changes are already made by someone outside of the challenge.

“Can’t Complete” – If you were not able to make edits due to low-quality, outdated or unavailable imagery, or conflicting sources.

“Not an Issue” – If you find that the issue wouldn’t require a fix, and based on your knowledge, the map is correct as it is.

At TomTom we prioritize quality and usability in the challenges we share and value your feedback. If you have any input regarding this challenge or any other, feel free to reach out to us through the “Contact Challenge Owner” button, local forums, or by emailing OSM@tomtom.com.

Two gantries (with no other tags) exist - https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/1155948760 and https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/1155948759.

1 Like

Thanks for taking a look and pointing these out.

Re: the description, we’ll review it to keep it simple, clear and still informative enough.

Re: the mentioned item, https://maproulette.org/challenge/57035/task/364338104,

These features represent the physical gantry structure tagged as a way (man_made=gantry). The task would aim to add the nodes highway=toll_gantry to capture the toll cameras which are currently missing in OSM.

Thanks. Apologies ig I have missed it, but what is the source (and licence) of the “suggested” data?

The locations were reviewed by our local TomTom mappers based on combination of aerial, satellites and ground-level imageries (including TomTom proprietary data).

For information on payment and other details, they reviewed also operator websites and combined it to their local knowledge.

If any suggested information appears inaccurate or incomplete, please let us know.

We’ve also updated (simplified) a bit the challenge description.

Just a quick heads-up that our editor will likely start working on this challenge later today or, at latest, tomorrow.

Perhaps they could post here as they map so that people could comment?

1 Like

Let me take a look at what’s feasible and I’ll get back to you.

Hi everyone,
I am going to start working on this challenge on Monday. I will keep you posted and share the changeset links as I map.

2 Likes