Bus stops in Norway [guide for understanding current data and reporting problems]

FennecusZerda · 2023-11-03T14:03:46.048Z

Mindre endringer i Tyholtveien i Trondheim - Cecilie Thoresens veg:

Where: (ref:nsrq 75585) Node: ‪Cecilie Thoresens veg‬ (‪2184041539‬) | OpenStreetMap
Where: (ref:nsrq 75582) Node: ‪Cecilie Thoresens veg‬ (‪2184041538‬) | OpenStreetMap
What: Nybygget sykkelveg med fortau, begge busstopp flyttet litt vestover.

Plankart i plandokument
Bilder under “Forkjørsvei og 40-sone”

sbre · 2024-01-23T23:38:00.680Z

Where: (ref:nsrq 68882) Node: ‪Straumen‬ (‪6372450264‬) | OpenStreetMap
What: Adjust position northwest by 40 metres

Actual location of the stop, surveyed on site.

(Do upstream changes actually happen, or has this import effectively caused bus stops to be impossible to correct in OSM?)

Wulfmorn · 2024-01-24T09:23:42.475Z

sbre:

Adjust position northwest by 40 metres

you mean like this?

image897×723 32.7 KB

Upstream changes do happen, but sometimes eventually. The fylkeskommuner are responsible for doing this. Sometimes I do it for them with obvious easy fixes, but sometimes I leave them a note and they’ll do it when they do it.

sbre · 2024-01-24T10:52:42.782Z

Red marker is spot on

Wulfmorn · 2024-01-24T11:16:02.414Z

sbre:

spot on

Good. I’ve saved the change in NSR

sbre · 2024-04-27T16:57:10.433Z

Dont move or rename the stops

I will be renaming stops form now on, as the suggested process for reporting errors does not seem to have any effect.

Wulfmorn · 2024-04-27T16:59:02.056Z

which stops?

sbre · 2024-04-27T17:05:04.641Z

ref:nsrq 73067, 71282, 73480, 73830, 71761, 72337, 73084, 71149 (name)
ref:nsrq 70203 (position)

Wulfmorn · 2024-04-27T17:33:28.241Z

If you edit the names for yourself according to your own opinions they won’t match the stop names in local and national journey planners. I know you disagree with the names but wrong names are better than mismatching names. I can nudge AtB about it and see what they say.

Your inputs are still registered in NSR, just not processed by AtB yet.

NKA · 2024-04-28T20:06:58.206Z

Enklest å legge inn loc_name=* ?

sbre · 2024-04-28T20:13:40.821Z

Blir vel minst friksjon slik inntil vidare.

Wulfmorn · 2024-05-16T11:27:19.211Z

@sbre Nå har jeg ringt AtB og purret litt ekstra. Har god tro på relativt rask behandling nå

zidel · 2024-05-21T10:30:24.896Z

ref:nsrq=9252 (Jahr) har fått en platform 150m nord for noden i OSM

Wulfmorn · 2024-05-22T14:15:37.736Z

Ruter har notert. Blir endret ifbm neste ruteeksport (gjetter på maks 1 uke)

Wulfmorn · 2024-05-23T07:34:05.879Z

@sbre AtB har begynt å endre på stoppene du anbefalte endringer på, men noe av det må ventes med (det må lages nye lydfiler og slikt - til bussene, og nye skilt).

Wulfmorn · 2024-06-03T09:41:52.907Z

@sbre AtB har gjort endringene sine på Hitra nå.

Wulfmorn · 2024-08-09T08:07:53.221Z

Bare melder litt generelt nå at, ja, fylkene ivaretar meldingene dere leverer inn. Noen gang tar det litt tid, noen gang blir det på en måte “avslag”, men alt som oftest blir det en forbedring som føyes inn. Keep 'em coming.

FennecusZerda · 2024-10-10T09:39:51.102Z

Funnet noe som kan rettes på:

Hvor: ref:nsrq 4188 Kjølstad‬ (‪6373483183‬)
Rettelse: Må flyttes ca. 50 meter lengre sørvest.

sbre · 2024-10-10T10:20:20.605Z

ref:nsrq 10892
Denne står som “Tuvhaugen”, noko dei lokale irriterar seg litt over. Tuvhaugen er rett nok ein haug som ligg eit stykke innover på myrene her, men staden stoppen ligg og alle husa er har namnet “Melkneset”.

Wulfmorn · 2024-10-10T11:30:28.638Z

Fikset…