Are data consumers well-represented in the OSM community?

As a mapper, I’m always interested in discussion on tagging schemas, bulk edits, etc. I am also a regular (end-) consumer of OSM data, mostly via general-purpose mobile apps. But I almost never see data consumers participating in the discussion.

  1. Is there someplace where consumers like Mapbox, GIS professionals, OsmAnd, and others are discussing their needs and challenges?
  2. Do we (as mappers) even care, or is it basically “you get what you get”?
  3. If there is nowhere already and we do indeed care, any ideas on how we can get better feedback from the consumers?

As volunteers and providers of the free data, I don’t think we should have to conform to the desires of our downstream consumers. But perhaps it would be interesting to us and helpful to them to have some info on what they’re struggling with, what’s easy and what’s hard, and so on.

5 Likes

I suspect that there are a pretty fair number of people representing data consumers monitoring and contributing to discussions about tagging. But I also suspect that they are using their own names or nom de mapping identities so you may not recognize them as representing data consumers.

There certainly were and I believe still are representatives from the two hiking apps that are popular in the USA contributing to the trail tagging initiative.

Back when turn lane tagging and associated turn restriction relations were new and not yet settled down, I recall people who seemed to be associated with various car navigation apps chiming in.

On a much smaller scale, I create my own hiking maps based on OSM and other data and I have certainly chimed in when tagging I care about is being discussed and I have modified my map generation scripts over time to adjust to new and revised tagging.

5 Likes

State of the Map has a bit of everything: hobby mappers, GIS professionals, open-source app developers (of both editors and consumer-facing apps), people working in the humanitarian sector / HOTOSM space, people working at organisations with specific interests (e.g. mapping of golf courses), …

3 Likes

Some software developers participate in this forum to varying degrees, and some even prefer feedback to go here instead of their own issue trackers. But it’s a bit of a fire hose, covering so much ground with a significant level of noise and drama. The discussions here take time away from actually developing software, so I know a lot of developers who don’t bother. If anything is important enough to require their attention, someone will come to them, the thinking goes.

There are other venues for coordination. Some developers have gravitated towards OSMUS Slack over the years, treating it as their sole real-time communication channel, so there’s some organic interaction among them. I’d imagine the other big national communities have seen something similar in their corners. Those who have the means will congregate a few times a year at conferences, as mentioned. OSMF and OSMUS convene working groups to provide a space for more frequent coordination, though this capability is underutilized. Technically there’s still a dev mailing list intended for discussion among software developers and announcements geared to them. But all of the discussion since December 2024 has been about shutting down the list for inactivity.

The relationship between mappers and developers has had ups and downs. At times it feels like an adversarial relationship, due to small things, like a knee-jerk admonition to avoid “mapping for the renderer” solely because a renderer or router motivates someone to ask. Conversely, for a developer, it can be tempting to add some behavior because it’s technically straightforward, while they lack the experience, patience, or social capital to shepherd their idea through a community consultation process. That’s especially true these days, when “anyone can be their own developer” with an LLM coding agent.

OSM doesn’t exist in a vacuum. Various fields like geography/GIS, natural sciences, and cartography all know us, even if they think of us as a read-only static dataset. There’s a ripe opportunity for us to improve the relationship just by showing up in their spaces, online and at conferences. I can’t tell you how often people in these fields tell me that they’ve never met a real-life OSM mapper before and have no idea how our “company” manages to do it all.

(As OSMF’s Core Software Development Facilitator, a big part of my job is to bridge these divides, get people talking to resolve misunderstandings and miscommunication. Most of it is behind the scenes and isn’t a replacement for mappers and developers coordinating directly among themselves. Formally, my job is limited to a definition of “core software”, for some definition thereof, but regardless I’m always happy to help connect the dots as long as I’m around. So if you do see something falling through the cracks, please don’t hesitate to reach out. The worst case scenario is that I have to pull in someone else who’s in a better position to help.)

19 Likes

There is the Advisory Board, which seats mostly corporate members of the OSMF (i.e. data consumers) as well as local chapters. Though according to the OSMF’s website their communications are mostly private.

For some reason they communicate through a :t_rex:mailing list​:sauropod:

France / the French-speaking world has Fédération des Pros d’OSM, which is distinct from the OSM France local chapter.

2 Likes

And on the French speaking forum they put their FPOSM membership in their profile.
They are normal people :wink:. We have also a category for GIS specialists working for the administration (towns, etc).

1 Like

I think that would be a great idea to have a space for that, and it don’t think we have one.
Disclaimer I’m not a developer, just a mapper (not much of a tagger[1]).

I first thought of a space here on this forum, but it would quickly be the same crowd as in General talk > Tagging general discussion and Help and support > Tagging help & support and I don’t think much developers not already here would join. I must admit it’s often quite a lot to read and I can imagine devs not wanting to wade in these.

But developers use issue trackers, and I think it could be a good medium for exchange between taggers and devs, to inform of decisions one side or the other, or even decide collectively.

GitHub has best coverage, most devs already have an account, Codeberg is better[2] (comaps already use it kind of this way, see governance).

So a good point is the low entry barrier for dev, they may links or sync with projects issues and MRs, but it might be overwhelming for some mappers.

I imagine tags for thematics: routing, rendering, etc. So a maintainer of carto would like to follow the tag “rendering” and not others. Also tags to highlight discussions, notices (Proposal RFC), decisions (we did or decided this) and such.

I would be happy to hear what you think about it !


  1. Not sure this word is a thing. Just mean someone who engage actively in the design, discussion and proposal of tags. Also people who like to invent new tags ATYL. ↩︎

  2. not M$ ↩︎

1 Like

Amusingly, using the mailing list feature of Discourse (the software powering this discussion forum/board) makes filtering to specific tags and other keywords feasible. I use Thunderbird, which has a robust filtering and tagging system for email, for this purpose. It’s not “dead simple” to set up, but it’s not “super hard” either (and, because Discourse tries to set special email headers for their data to be more easily consumed, I’ve periodically pondered making a Thunderbird WebExtension, to make my ad-hoc system more “dead simple” for others as well). The tags and keywords I’m interested in get highlighted. Sections I’m not super interested in get marked read automatically and ignored. If, after reading through a bit of a thread, I think I have nothing to contribute or watch for, I can hide it as well.

Mind you, nothing replaces human beings staying in touch with other human beings. This approach, for me at least, just makes it possible to do so; the alternative is getting pigeon-holed into siloed environments (e.g., Slack, Discord) and/or drowning in a firehouse of unclassified messages (e.g., traditional high-volume mailing lists without filtering and tagging tools).

A recent example, where the DeFlock app was used to create some questionable objects:

Because I use the mailing list feature and watch tags like deflock, this thread popped up for me. I was able to dig in, and then reach out to the devs on GitHub, linking them back to the OSM thread:

1 Like

One of the big pushes for the Trails Stewardship Initiative was to bring together mappers, trail stewards, and app developers. It’s honestly a great thing to get everyone together and trying to solve sticky issues together.

I know the DeFlock folks try pretty hard to stay on top of things… but there’s a lot, so I will ping them with stuff that pops up from time to time.

1 Like

It also exposes the threads in the discussion which are hidden on the web page!

1 Like

I’d say they either think of OSM as another GIS database handed to them; or just adapt to whatever tagging is present in OSM.

There are a handful of commercial data consumers on here, mostly in that area of the Venn diagram between OSM contributor/activist and data consumer - people like me, @woodpeck , @Andy_Allan.

But I’d caution against overstating the importance of discussions on “tagging schemas, bulk edits, etc.” to most data consumers. 90% of commercial consumers use 10% of tags, largely the ones that have been settled for years. Our main concern with new tagging schemas and bulk edits, I think, is that they don’t screw up that 10%.

I do think a better job could be done of informing data consumers of tagging changes (and I’m carefully using the passive voice to elide whether that’s the responsibility of OSMF or the tagwanker[1] in question), and that tagwankers should give more thought to how their changes will play out in downstream applications. OSM is no longer just a hobby project, it’s the underpinning of some very socially significant applications and we should behave accordingly.


  1. Used in the affectionate sense of the early/mid-00s geowanking list. ↩︎

8 Likes

Yep! And apparently, Discourse has an alternative view available that exposes the threads in the web page too. It looks much like Reddit’s threading. They call it “nested replies”.

People on Discord last week were saying how much they prefer that system over what we have here. But as I pointed out then, it’s handy when the conversation is over & done with quickly, but when you come in a few hours later, see a question way back up ^ that hasn’t been answered, or want to comment on something, then you’ve got to try to drag that topic back to the present, which doesn’t always work :thinking:

Out of nearly 3,000 respondents to the 2021 survey over 1,600 self-identified as data users. See the summary stats here. 1,371 self-identified as both mappers and data users.

5 Likes

I’m just a lowly user :smiley: so I have nothing to contribute to mapping / data (other than a couple of minor local edits) but I’ve asked a question or two before. My usage of OSM is almost entirely related to driving. I’m in Louisiana, so no one in their right mind has an interest in hiking, etc. LOL