Anyone got low quality surface=grass_paver that they can take photo of?

Something that is hard to pass with regular car?

All I have seen and could make photos of and all found on Commons are well-passable by car.

If someone can upload photo to Wikimedia Commons it would allow to fill gap in Key:smoothness/Gallery - OpenStreetMap Wiki (and take us step closer to Smoothness overlay · Issue #5486 · streetcomplete/StreetComplete · GitHub )

See also How to map Key:smoothness

This?


2 Likes

yes, that would be very helpful!

ideally it would be in perspective similar to StreetComplete/app/src/androidMain/res/drawable-hdpi/surface_asphalt_good.jpg at master · streetcomplete/StreetComplete · GitHub

best upload to Wikimedia Commons full sized image and then crop something for StreetComplete once set of images for various smoothness is collected

Can you upload them to Wikimedia Commons?

1 Like

I can provide even worse ones in a day or two — tree roots heavily damaged parking spots over the years, so I’m often forced to use the worst spots.

However, I’m uncertain what this is supposed to be used for: grass paver is normally only used for parking lots and like, and we don’t tag those for smoothness.

1 Like

normally yes, but…

and nowadays surface=grass_paver is covering nearly entire Way: ‪Basztowa‬ (‪117810705‬) | OpenStreetMap (wait, I thought I mapped surface there?)

I have seen some in other places of Poland, most often on road on slopes with high incline where erosion after rain was especially likely and road was not a public road. Presumably surface=asphalt has much higher cost independent from how large area is being paved, making it inefficient for tiny sections. While bringing few concrete blocks has more or less linear costs with much lower fixed part.
Also, seems more likely in places where heavy equipment like agricultural or logging machines may pass, probably paving_stones are more prone to be damaged by them.

Smoothness overlay · Issue #5486 · streetcomplete/StreetComplete · GitHub and Key:smoothness/Gallery - OpenStreetMap Wiki

BTW, perspective for photos ideally would be kind of like

1 Like

I took the photos, but now I cannot access my old Commons account because security… :rage:

Those two are the best worst I could get at that moment. Are they good bad enough? Should I crop the car wheel from the second?


Edit: uploaded to Commons as

I prefer this one, because it is as bad as the one used on SC for bad paving_stones

In the meantime, I added one of yours and one of mine to Key:smoothness/Gallery.

1 Like

And I guess that one so damaged that heavy-duty off road vehicles are needed is not really possible?

Even more for " tractors, ATVs, tanks, trial and mountain bikes, misc. off-highway vehicles"

intermediate - upper end

Imgur

intermediate

Imgur

Imgur
Imgur
Imgur

intermediate - lower end

Imgur

bad

1 Like